10 Best Eye Creams As Voted by You

The Truth In Aging community reviews every product on our site and in our shop, so Marta and team surveyed our top contributors to find out which eye creams and serums get their vote...if they had to choose just one. These are your best eye cream and serum picks.

AQ Skin Solutions Eye Serum ($99 in the shop) 

AQ is the best. It makes a huge difference in the puffiness and the firmness. I also see a difference in my lashes. Gloria

AQ is the best for me. I like the consistency of a serum. It is hydrating not drying. It firms and reduces puffiness. It does make the eyelashes grow as Marta has attested to. I even dab it on my brows! It is a multi-tasker and definitely the best eye product I have found for my mature 47 year young eye area. Terri

Forced to pick just one, I'll stick with the AQ serum. It's the most firming and smoothing. Emily

AQ Eye Serum. It seems to really make my eyes look more youthful and I like the fact that it can possibly make my eyelashes grow longer with the growth factor ingredient. Tina

AQ Skin solutions Eye Serum: It really does the job of softening fine lines and firming eye lids. A bit pricey but in the long run, it is of good value since just a little amount glides smoothly and evenly around both eyes and there might be enough to last for around 6+ months and that's a long time! Imelda

Read the full review for AQ Skin Solutions Eye Serum here

Your Best Face Correct ($150 in the shop) 

YBF Correct depuffs, invigorates, hydrates without being too greasy. Against all other eye creams I have tried over the past 5 years, Correct always ends up being the best performing for me! —Junko

YBF Correct keeps fine lines in check and firms my brows. But what really sets it apart from the competition is its effectiveness on dark circles. YBF Correct wakes up my face by quickly lightening and brightening my lids and under-eyes. —Erica

YBF Correct without any doubt. It tackles everything: fine lines, dark circles, puffiness, creepiness. —Katya

Read full review of Your Best Face Correct here

Michael Todd True Organics Intensive Organic Eye Cream 

I've only purchased the Michael Todd cream but I like it a lot. It absorbs well, doesn't irritate my eyes at all (a problem with other products in the past), and keeps the skin around my eyes well hydrated. —Becky

I like Michael Todd Intensive Organics eye cream because it contains proven effective agents to fight sagginess, dark circles and fine lines. It contains approx. 77% organic ingredients. It is soothing and has helped to tighten the area around my eyes, including the top lid which is amazing. I am especially fond of the price point! —Kimberly

I'm still searching for my *perfect* eye cream, but until I do, I'm pleased to have made the acquaintance with Michael Todd's Intensive Eye Treatment. It is quickly absorbed by the skin, leaving it soft and hydrated (no problem applying makeup afterwards). I've just used it for three weeks but this product has come to stay. —Gunilla

Read full review of Michael Todd Organics Intensive Organic Eye Cream here

Amarte Eyeconic Eye Cream ($80) 

I think the Amarte Eye Cream performed beautifully with a gentle retinol that really did smooth the undereye area without irritation.Mark

I love the Amarte Eyeconic. I followed some recommendations from other users and made it my under-makeup eye cream. It has made a noticeable difference in the visibility of my creases. The cream is light, soaks in quickly, and has an applicator that delivers the exact right amount. Great stuff! —Ann

Read full review here

Skinfinite LOL Eye Serum ($49 in the shop) 

Skinfinite LOL is my current eye cream. It reduces puffiness very well and helps with under eye circles. —Denise

Read full review here

Mukti Age Defense Eye Serum ($91) 

Although it is labeled a "serum," it is actually a dense cream. This organic eye cream drenches your delicate eye area in moisture and does an excellent job of minimizing crows feet. —Valerie

Read full review here

And there were other eye cream and serums (we’ll call them our runner-ups) that received votes that made the list, too:

Arcona Eye Dew - read full review here

Osmotics Eye Surgery Under Eye Rejuvenator - read full review here

ReLuma Eye Cream  - read full review here 

Snowberry Smoothing Eye Serum read full review here