Free shipping on all domestic orders over $39

Find the eye cream that meets your needs

Find the eye cream that meets your needs
April 18, 2012 Reviewed by Marta 2 Comments

Eye creams are an absolute necessity for most of us as we get older. However, seeing eye to eye on the best cream, gel or serum isn’t always obvious and finding the right one can be a challenge. Although there are eye creams that purport to be all-rounders that can tackle everything from dark circles to wrinkles, my advice is to decide what condition is your priority and choose an eye cream that is best formulated to tackle it. Here are some ideas:

Best for dark circles

There are some specific ingredients that can be of some help and they are a key feature of some the newest, good quality eye creams. They include Hesperidin methyl chalcone, Bioskinup Contour 3r, Haloxyl and Eyeseryl. Read more on the causes of and solutions for dark under eye circles. Eye creams that major on these actives and have had readers reporting results with dark circles include Hydropeptide Dark Circle Concentrate ($60 and winner of the 2011 Five Best Eye Creams for Under $65); Your Best Face Correct ($150 in the TIA shop), Skin Nutrition Eye Reconditioning Cream ($110 ), Belli Eye Brightening Cream also gets good reports relying mostly on arnica and panax ginseng as does IQ Derma RestorEyes ($85).

Best for puffy eyes

If you are saddled with bags then keep an eye out for Eyeseryl. This is tetrapeptide-5 and it is supposed to reduce water retention and ensure lymph drainage, while protecting collagen from cross-linking and causing baggy eyes. Additionally, it reduces leaking of fluids from the capillaries into the tissue, which can cause puffy eyes. Bioskinip Contour 3r reduced eye bags by 50% in a trial, according to the manufacturer. Eyeseryl can be found in ReLuma’s eye cream ($81 in the TIA shop) as does YBF Refresh ($80 in the TIA shop) - read a review of them tested side by side, while Chella Anti-Fatigue Eye Mask Kit ($45) has Bioskinup, Sevani Ageless Eyes ($54 in the TIA shop) got a good review from our puffy-eye prone 30-something tester and Beautisol Eye Want is good at de-puffing in my experience. Our reviewer also got great (as in eliciting comments from husband) results with LiftLab’s Lift & Firm Eye Cream ($95)

Best for crepey lines

Delicate eye area skin seems to be prone to a specific kind of dry wrinklyness that is known as crepeyness. Slathering on a rich moisturizer isn’t necessarily the answer, at least not for me. I was only able to actually eliminate crepe (probably my most successful anti-aging experience to date) when I made the investment in Your Best Face Correct. Although this eye cream is formulated to be an all-rounder, eliminating crepey wrinkles is what it does best.

Best for firming

The hunt is still on for the ultimate firming and lifting eye cream, but in the meantime there are some that give noticeable results. Users of SenZen Double Dose eye cream ($84) report firming and hydration. I should point out that some people found it initially hydrating and then drying. My take on it is that if you want firming, give it a try and add in a little of your regular moisturizer if needed. If you are on a budget, try Reviva Labs DMAE Firming Eye Serum. Don’t expect miracles, but it is a good maintenance product for a mere $19. LiftLab’s Lift & Firm also does what it says on the tin (note that testers have said it takes two-to-three weeks to get results).

Best for hydration

The eye area’s delicate skin can become easily dry and malnourished. The trick is to find hydrating eye creams that aren’t too heavy and play nice with makeup without pilling. La Vie Celeste’s eye cream ($60 in the TIA shop) is a good choice as it leaves the skin with, in the words of one reviewer, a “creamy matte finish”. Dark circles will appreciate the brightening effects of bearberry with a natural alpha arbutin. Smoothing, brightening and moisturizing effects were experienced by our tester with Juice Beauty’s Stem Cellular Repair Eye Treatment ($45).

Best for crow’s feet

Paradoxically, I’ve not yet found an eye cream that does a really good job on crow’s feet. So I recommend getting out the heavy guns – serums and even the PaloVia at home laser device. Our testers absolutely raved about the results they got with PaloVia ($499), although the treatment is not for the faint of heart. I’ve recently been using Skin Nutrition’s Night Cream ($75 in the TIA shop) with very good effect, inspired by our tester’s before and after pictures. I’ve also had good results with BioEffect, ReLuma Serum and the new formulation of Your Best Face Control.

Applying eye cream

My esthetician, Ildi Pekar, taught me to apply eye cream with a gentle circular motion that starts at the outer eye, travels under the eye towards the nose and then over the lid. In other words, the opposite direction from your wrinkles.

  • April 18, 2012

    by Susan S.

    Hi Marta,
    I LOVE the Sen Zen for the firming and, for me anyway, brightening of the eye area. I've really noticed a difference. But I do have crepiness and I was allergic to Correct (this is no judgement on their product as although I seem to be able to put anything on my face, my eyes are picky picky and very few products do not irritate them.) so I was wondering if you found any other of the products you've used kind of worked for the crepiness?

  • April 18, 2012

    by Oksana

    Very interesting, Marta
    My under-eye skin is very dry; currently, I sm using Juice Stem cell serum and Evan Healy Chamomile eyecream. The Juice serum is too dry on its own. Evan's cream provides just enough hydration and does not interfere with concealer.
    I am looking forward to trying Correct again - crepiness be gone! Will use with Evan's chamomile cream just to be sure.
    Had to succumb to the notion, that it is not always possible to find A magic bullet. Sometimes you need a couple of them to do the trick.

Join the discussion! Leave a comment below.

My Comment

Add a comment...

-or- Cancel Comment
* Required Fields
truth in aging's five best

Truth In Aging's Five Best

The very best to choose from for your skin concerns.

Read More

truth in aging videos

Truth In Aging Videos

Helpful how-tos and reviews from Marta and friends.

Watch Now

meet our contributors

Meet Our Contributors

The TIA community consists of our trusted reviewers.

Meet Them

be inspired

Be Inspired

Inspiring thoughts and women who are aging gracefully.

Read More