Free shipping on all domestic orders over $39

Reviewed and Rejected: Kirkland Signature Age-Defying Protective Eye Cream

March 25, 2009 Reviewed by Marta 4 Comments
Did you know that in the US over 6,000 people a year are hospitalized as a result of a packaging injury? In the UK, the annual cost to the National Health Service around $25m. If you don't believe me when I say that opening a box can be hazardous, then take a trip to Costco. I recently did (my first since arriving in the US nine years ago) and bought, along with extremely large jars of things that I didn't really need such as capers, a couple of things from Costco's own cosmetic line, Kirkland Signature by Borghese.

The packaging is conceptually curious - an inflexible cardboard panel into which is set a kind of molded plastic bubble that houses the product (I chose the Age-Defying Protective Eye Cream for $26.99) - and nearly lethal in practice. I didn't actually cut myself in the process of getting at my pot of eye cream but I did work up a muck sweat wrestling with the damn thing. A variety of tools were called into service with little avail. Neither scissors, teeth or a bread knife could make a dent although both me and the packaging looked as if we'd been backed over by a truck. In the end, I raided by husband's tool box and found a small saw. True story! It did the trick.

Even though Costco's packaging is both consumer and environmentally unfriendly, I was determined to make friends with the eye cream. The price was good (although it should be pointed out that it comes in a Liliputian - compared to everything else at Costco - half ounce pot) and many of the ingredients were good enough to pass muster.

After two weeks of testing, I gave up. The skin around my eyes began to look a tad dry and crepey. Far from 'Age-Defying', Kirkland's eye cream was age-advancing. Why this should be is almost as perplexing as how to unpackage it without becoming unhinged. The ingredients are, if not standouts, anti-aging stalwarts at the very least. Rice bran, wheat bran and green tea are good antioxidants. Ceramide has been shown in some studies to help rebuild and restore the epidermal barrier, strengthening the skin’s appearance and maximizing its moisture levels. It even has a botanical that is new to me: menyanthes trifoliata leaf extract. This alone could be worth getting to know better since it is supposed to be a scavenger of peroxynitrite, a free radical that creates lipid peroxidation.

There is nothing to dislike (except the inclusion of every paraben known to man), but somehow me and Kirkland's eye cream were't compatible. But I guess I should have known that when I needed power tools to facilitate the introduction.

Water, C12-15 alkyl benzoate, cetearyl alcohol, yeast extract, hydrolized rice bran protein, stearyl ethylhexanoate, butylene glycol, aloe barbadensis leaf extract, octyldodecyl erucate, ceteareth-20, sweet almond seed extract, soybean seed extract, camellia oleifera leaf extract, wheat bran extract, menyanthes trifoliata leaf extract, ceramide-3, panthenol, allantoin, propylene glycol, squalane, carbomer, bisabolol, glycyrrhetinic acid, glyceryl polymethacrylate, trisodium EDTA, cholesterol, lecithin, triethanolomine, phenoxyethanol, methylparaben, butylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben, isobutylparaben
  • March 25, 2009

    by marta

    That's not a bad thought. If anything, I do seem to be more sensitive to the nasties than I used to be. Plus I have higher expectations now that I've been finding some really good products, free of parabens and full of things that seem to work.

  • March 25, 2009

    by marta

    It's the price on the CostCo website. I agree, we normally test products for much longer. But as this was actually having an adverse effect, I stopped. That's why I made of point of saying I used it for only two weeks before giving up.

    Still, I am glad you like it.

  • March 25, 2009

    by JulieK

    I wonder if we *treat* our face over time by using products that don't use parabens and/or ureas, that when we do (and in such amounts- five!) they don't have harsh(er) affects, such as you experienced. Just thinking... ~jk

  • March 25, 2009

    by Denise Parker

    I have tried the Kirkland Signature Eye Cream and actually like it. I purchased it for lesser than $26.99, not sure where you purchased yours. I think it's fair to try a product for more than 2 weeks because it takes a while for your skin to get used to it. But, to each her own.

Join the discussion! Leave a comment below.

My Comment

Add a comment...

-or- Cancel Comment
* Required Fields
truth in aging's five best

Truth In Aging's Five Best

The very best to choose from for your skin concerns.

Read More

truth in aging videos

Truth In Aging Videos

Helpful how-tos and reviews from Marta and friends.

Watch Now

meet our contributors

Meet Our Contributors

The TIA community consists of our trusted reviewers.

Meet Them

be inspired

Be Inspired

Inspiring thoughts and women who are aging gracefully.

Read More